Entities

Facs

Tillich Lectures

Transcript

[256]

later on, in terms of seemingly miraculous ways, but actually in terms of tricks.

The reductionist philosophers became aware that in reality they did this trick and that it is not dignified to stick to it, after they had seen the tricky character of the reductionist method. So they accepted a concept of nature (“naturalism” is derived from “nature”) which could keep their claim to be naturalists. But we can now call this not reductionism, but integrated naturalism, which means that one calls everything “nature,” including the creation of Shakespeare's plays, or the Bible—no one can prevent anyone from calling this “nature,” or calling it an expression of human nature. But then the concept of nature loses its contrary, and this kind of naturalism could perhaps be criticized by cs fallacy of the lacking contrast1: if you call everything “nature,” then the name loses its real meaning.

But nevertheless the important thing is not the matter of the name, but it is that the reductionist trick was given up. That is one of the steps to the return of man to himself. He discovered that the levels of reality cannot be reduced to one. Then the question was: which is their unity?

This leads to another discovery, and a very important one, which was first made in psychology, namely the so-called Gestalt- psychology. I intend to use this German word, which has become a foreign word in English, because there is no real translation for it. The transcription of the meaning, or the description of the meaning, of this word is perhaps “a living structure,” or “an independent structure.” The word “structure” is not a good translation because every


Footnotes, Editorial notes

1 It is impossible to say with certainty exactly which of James’s works he has in mind. William James addresses this issue frequently. In his lectures on pragmatism, for example, he says in Lecture II: “The pragmatic method in such cases is to try to interpret each notion by tracing its respective practical consequences. What difference would it practically make to anyone if this notion rather than that notion were true? If no practical difference whatever can be traced, then the alternatives mean practically the same thing, and all dispute is idle. Whenever a dispute is serious, we ought to be able to show some practical difference that must follow from one side or the other’s being right.” (What Pragmatism Means, in William James, Pragmatism. A New Name for Some old Ways of Thinking, Myers Education Press 2019, 30) or describes the “world’s unity” in Lecture IV (“The One and the Many“) as “definite networks”, “everything that exits is influences in some way by something else” (32).

Register

aReductionism
bNaturalism
cJames, William
dPsychology
eGestalt

Entities

Keywords

Persons

TL-0260.pdfTL-0259.htmlTL-0261.html